Clover Hill Farm: the former John Beecher-Roger Sherman-James Hillhouse property

What do we know about the history of the land currently owned by the Town of Woodbridge and operated today as the Country Club of Woodbridge? An article in the New Haven Register back around the time of the Town’s purchase in 2009 tells a portion of the tale of the founding of the former “Woodbridge Country Club” in the 1940s:

“The land near Johnson Road that is now home to the WCC once was an abandoned golf course that was constructed partially in 1931, then finished in 1935. The first club thrived until World War II began, then closed.

Shapiro said her father and 100 other men bankrolled the revival of the course, which had been overgrown. A clubhouse soon was created, and fire twice burned it down. The club thrived until the 1980s and since then the number of members has declined and debt escalated into the millions, now threatening its future.”

But what of earlier times? Let’s assemble some clues!

clover_hill_farm_Wd_Hills_photo

Here is the “James L. Nesbit Home” as it was featured on page four of the book Woodbridge Hills, published in 1911 by the the Woodbridge Civic Association. The photo caption reads:

Probably built between 1745-50, by Capt. John Beecher, who sold it to Roger Sherman in 1766. This illustrious owner sold it to James Abraham Hillhouse in 1773. Widow Hillhouse, in 1801, gives “my Amity Farm” to nephew James Hillhouse, who sold it to Timothy Fowler in 1835. Purchased by the present owner in 1903.

My, what a collection of historical figures we have in that short paragraph! Let’s begin with Captain John Beecher — he has quite a tale to tell us…

Who was Captain John Beecher?

Referred to here as John Beecher, Jr., he was actually the third in succession to bear this name and was born on September 5, 1722 in New Haven. He was a great-grandson of  Isaac Beecher who was born in Kent, England in 1623 and arrived in the New Haven colony in 1638 with his widowed mother. In 1645 Isaac married Mary Sperry, a sister of Richard Sperry who we know as the first European settler to live in present-day Woodbridge, then a part of the New Haven Colony. Isaac and Mary Beecher named the firstborn of their five sons John (1645-1712) after Isaac’s father, who was the first European settler to die in the New Haven Colony — here is a recounting of that story, taken in part from the History of the Colony of New Haven, page 42:

The Beecher family finds its beginnings in Kent, England in 1594 with the birth of John Beecher. John was the first Beecher to arrive in the New World, arriving on the ship Hector in 1637. John did not survive the first winter. Wife Hannah arrived the following spring with her son Isaac, and found her husband had been buried in an unmarked grave.

“In the autumn of 1637, Mr. Eaton and others of the company made a journey to Connecticut, to explore the lands and harbors on the coast, and being pleased with the situation of Quinnipiack, they there determined to settle their colony. On what is now the south corner of Church and Meadow streets, they erected a hut, in which a few men remained during the winter.

Seven men were left by Eaton, four of whom were Francis Brown, John Beacher, Robert Pigg, and Thomas Hogg. One of the party died in the winter. In {the 175os}, when the cellar of the stone house on the corner of George and Meadow streets was dug, bones were found lying horizontally, almost entire. They were those of a large man, and believed to be the bones of this Englishman, as the Indians buried their dead in a different posture.”

So this original settler John Beecher was our John Beecher III’s  great-great-grandfather. Four generations later, our John was the only child to be born to the marriage of his parents John Beecher, Jr. (1696-1724) and Mehitable Tuttle (1699-after 1779). When John III was just two years old his father John Jr. died. His mother who was 24 years-old when she became a widow, married Barnabus Baldwin, Jr. (1692-after 1779) two years later, and John was raised in the Baldwin household in Woodbridge with 8 half-siblings.

The children and grandchildren of Mehitable and Barnabus Baldwin, Jr. figure prominently in the history of Woodbridge and much more can be read about them in the new edition of Woodbridge History. Here is a list of Mehitable’s children from both marriages:

Mehitable_children

For more information, you can also view a chart showing two more generations of Mehitable’s descendants — including 46 great-grandchildren, many of whom continued to raise their own families here in Woodbridge through the 1800s. (To view the chart details, click once on the link above to open the image, and once it appears, click again anywhere in that window to enlarge the image and scroll around to read.)

Barnabus Baldwin Jr. owned many acres of land in the vicinity of the present-day Ansonia Road, stretching from Racebrook Road all the way to the intersection of Ansonia and Rimmon roads where Fountain Street ends.

Barnabus granted property to John Beecher, his wife’s son from her first marriage, along with his other children, and this likely including the land where John built the house pictured above in the 1745 to 1750 timeframe. Other descendants of Barnabus and Mehitable also lived all along this road — see pages 29, 31, 35, 46, 47, 48 and 50 in the book Woodbridge History – 2nd Edition for details.

Roger Sherman, James Hillhouse, and subsequent owners

According to the 1911 entry in Woodbridge Hills, in 1766 John Beecher sold his home on Ansonia Road to Roger Sherman. This “illustrious owner” is, of course, the well-known Founding Father:

Roger_Sherman_1721-1793_by_Ralph_EarlRoger Sherman (April 19, 1721 – July 23, 1793) was an early American lawyer and statesman, as well as a Founding Father of the United States. He served as the first mayor of New Haven, Connecticut, and served on the Committee of Five that drafted the Declaration of Independence, and was also a representative and senator in the new republic. He was the only person to sign all four great state papers of the U.S.: the Continental Association; the Declaration of Independence; the Articles of Confederation, and; the Constitution.

Born and raised in towns near Boston, Massachusetts,  after his father’s death in 1741 his family moved to Connecticut, first settling in New Milford and then arriving in New Haven by June of 1761. After his service in our nation’s capital, Roger was serving as Mayor of New Haven upon his death in 1793.

But what is his connection with Woodbridge? We know that he owned land in New Haven before the Revolution and his property was situated along the present-day Forest Road near the Hopkins School. Looking at a map, we can see the proximity of this area with the land currently occupied by the Country Club of Woodbridge.

CCW_area_map

But there is a family connection to Woodbridge for Roger Sherman, as well. Let’s look back on some of the history of the Congregational Church, found in Reverdy Whitlock’s wonderful book, The Parish of Amity, on page 168:

“Reverend Josiah Sherman… eight years younger than his famed brother, the Honorable Roger Sherman” was selected to serve as minister in Woodbridge “early in the summer of 1789… [but the] contract died with Mr. Sherman only a few months later.”

Here is Josiah Sherman’s gravestone in Eastside Cemetery today, along with a description of his passing, below, quoted from the History of New Haven, Chapter VI, published in 1892:

287

The tombstone of Reverend Josiah Sherman, who died very suddenly while laboring with the church, has the following inscription: “In memory of Rev. Josiah Sherman, minister of the Gospel, Ob. Nov. 24 A D 1789, M. 60. The learned scholar, the eloquent orator, the exemplary Christian, the faithful pastor, the kind husband and parent, and the humble follower of Jesus Christ. Piety adorned his useful life and in the moments of a painful death enabled him to triumph in the hope of heaven. Much impressed himself and conscious of his awful danger, by him the violated law spoke its thunders and by him in strains as sweet as ever angels use the Gospel whispered peace.”

Going back to the chronology of the property, we see that Roger Sherman owned the land known then as Clover Hill Farm from 1766 to 1773 when he sold it to James Abraham Hillhouse. This was the uncle who raised the noted public servant, James Hillhouse. Here is a brief biographical sketch gathered from various sources:

Etching of Connecticut lawyer, politician and businessman James Hillhouse, executed by the American printmaker A.H. Ritchie, circa 1800-1830. Image courtesy of the Manuscripts & Archives Digital Images Database, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut.

Etching of James Hillhouse by A.H. Ritchie, courtesy of Yale Manuscripts & Archives.

“James Hillhouse (1754-1832) was born in Montville, Connecticut, the son of William Hillhouse and Sarah (Griswold) Hillhouse. At the age of seven, he was adopted by his childless uncle and aunt, James Abraham and Mary Lucas Hillhouse. He attended the Hopkins Grammar School in New Haven, Connecticut, graduated from Yale College in 1773, and practiced law in New Haven. During the Revolutionary War, Hillhouse served as captain of the Second Company of the Governor’s Foot Guard during the Tryon’s invasion of New Haven on July 5, 1779. Later, he was a member of the Connecticut House of Representatives (1780 to 1785), and elected as a United States Congressman from Connecticut (1791 to 1796), after which he was elected United States Senator serving from 1796 to 1810.”

James Hillhouse was also a driving force behind the creation of Grove Street Cemetery in New Haven in the aftermath of the yellow fever plague of 1794-95 during which it was recognized that continuing the practice of burials in the New Haven Green was having a negative impact on public health. Before this time, according to the history of the Grove Street Cemetery, “for the first one hundred-sixty odd years of her history, New Haven buried the dead in a common burying ground beneath and behind what is now Center Church on the Green.” It is notable that many of the original settlers of Woodbridge were buried in this common burial ground in New Haven, before the first burials in the Eastside Cemetery began to take place in the mid 1750s.

So, James Hillhouse received the property from his widowed adoptive mother in 1801, and held it until his death in 1832 apparently, after which it was transferred presumably by his estate, to the ownership of Timothy Fowler. This chain of ownership is also confirmed in a notation on the back of a photograph taken between 1935 and 1942 for a Works Project Administration (WPA) Architectural Survey of historic buildings, and included in the collection of the Connecticut State Library. Here is the photograph, entitled “Woodbridge Historic Building 023”:

Clover Hill Farm house - WPA Survey

Now, what else can we find to fill in the story on the next owner, Timothy Fowler?

The Fowler Family in Woodbridge

Well, look who we have here:

Timothy_and_Mary_Fowler

This image comes from a series of photographs in the collection of the Woodbridge & Amity Historical Society of people who called Woodbridge home in the 19th and early-20th century. The original photo of Timothy and Mary Fowler was photographed in the fall of 2014 along with a collection of more than a dozen albums of photographs belonging to a prominent family in town which were digitally photographed and cataloged and will become an important asset for the Historical Society as they are among the first entries in a digital catalog of items in their collection. Look for more information on this collection coming soon to the AWHS website.

A visit to Sperry Park, June 2015

What a lovely day to visit Sperry Park today. Before setting out, I’m rummaging around for some background information. Let’s start by gathering some old photos, shall we?
Sperry Bridge
First we have the photo “Bridge near Sperry’s Mills. Circa 1890.” as published in the Woodbridge Bicentennial Booklet. Under the photo the following text appears:

“Handsome gifts have been made to Woodbridge. Sperry Park perpetuates the name of our first settler. It was given in 1907 by the heirs of Enoch and Mary Atlanta Sperry, on the site of their home and in their memory.”

Well, that’s a start! Who are those folks perched up on the bridge in 1890? No clues for us… yet! A copy of this photo is in the collection at the Darling House… so we will have to dig there at some point. The text referring to “our first settler” of course refers to Richard and Dennis Sperry, the prolific couple from whom it is said 10 children and  60 grandchildren descend — read more about them in the post titled Sperry Family in Woodbridge.

But what else do we know about Enoch and Mary Atlanta themselves? And who exactly are their heirs who gifted this park to the Town in 1907? Let’s start with Mary: here she is in a photo taken towards the end of her long and eventful life.

Mary Atlanta Sperry

Turning to my genealogy records, I see that Mary Atlanta was my 3rd cousin, six times removed. She was born about 1795 here in Woodbridge and died at about age 69 on August 10th 1864. Find-a-Grave tells us she was buried at Westville Cemetery.

When Mary Atlanta married Enoch, presumably sometime shortly prior to 1820 when their first child was born, the couple must have known their kinship — their common ancestors, Richard and Dennis Sperry, were Enoch’s 2nd great-grandparents and Mary Atlanta’s 3rd great-grandparents, making them 2nd cousins once removed.

Enoch Sperry and I are more closely related — he is a son of my 6th great-grandparents, Simeon Sperry and Patience Smith. My line continues through Enoch’s sister Anna, who married into the Wooding family and had a daughter who married into my grandmother’s Lounsbury clan in Bethany. The park in Woodbridge is closely aligned to Enoch and Mary Atlanta, although we can see from an entry in the Town of Woodbridge Annual Report for 2014 that the land was also associated with Simeon and before him, his father Nathaniel 2nd. There’s no telling who built the original house that once stood on this “Sperry Home Lot” — was it Enoch (1787-1856), his father Simeon (1739-1805), or his grandfather Nathaniel (1695-1751)? But we do know that Enoch and Mary Atlanta eventually lived there. This screen from my genealogy database shows more details about their family.Enoch_and_Mary_Atlanta

Of their six children, born between 1820 and 1838, Mary and Enoch buried one child, Joseph Hart Sperry, who died at age 16 after being thrown from a horse in 1846. Then, just ten years later when Mary Atlanta was about 61 years-old, her husband was killed by an ax murderer on New Year’s Day 1856 in the woods near their home which was located on the present-day Sperry Park property. Vividly described in newspapers of the day, the killing shocked the small community of Woodbridge.

One can imagine that the impact of Mary Atlanta’s loss of her spouse in this violent manner can been seen in the expression she wears in the photo above, likely taken after Enoch’s death.

Of the couple’s five surviving children, we know the following information published in 1918 in “A Modern History of New Haven and eastern New Haven County, Volume 2”:

To the union of Enoch and Mary Atlanta Sperry were born children as follows: Hon. Lucien Wells Sperry born March 8 1820 in Woodbridge married Harriet A. Sperry daughter of Enos Sperry of Westville. She died about 1888 and Mr. Sperry in 1890. They left one daughter Mrs. Eugene S. Miller. At the age of seventeen years Lucien W. Sperry went to New Haven to learn the carpenter’s trade. As the years passed he improved his educational opportunities to such an extent that he was enabled to teach school. In 1845, associated with his brother Stiles D. Sperry, he began a mercantile career and for twenty years or more the brothers were located in business in Westville, Woodbridge, New Haven, and Hartford. In 1855 Lucien bought a tract of land on Mill river just east of the railroad and with Chauncey Sperry, son of the late Enos Sperry, engaged in the coal and wood business continuing same until 1863. In his later years he was connected with several local banks and was a director in railroads in which the town and city had interest. In the middle sixties he began a political career in which for many years he was most popular, prominent, and successful, holding almost every office in the gift of the people. His political affiliations were with the democratic party. In 1864 he was elected first selectman and held that office until 1868 when he declined renomination. In 1866 he was elected mayor of New Haven and was reelected in 1867 and again in 1868, receiving the largest majority ever given a candidate up to that time. In 1869 and 1870 he represented the fourth district in the state senate. From boyhood Mr. Sperry was identified with the militia of the state. When twenty he was chosen captain of a company formed in his native town and during the following year was appointed lieutenant colonel of the Second Regiment of which later he became colonel. He was captain and afterward major of the Second Company Governor’s Horse Guard.

Stiles Denison Sperry born October 15 1822 married Anna E. Briggs of Providence Rhode Island. He was a prominent merchant in New Haven and later served as treasurer of the State Savings Bank at Hartford holding that position at the time of his death. He served two terms as representative in the state legislature from Hartford. He was a prominent and influential Mason and held high offices in that fraternity.

Nehemiah D. Sperry was the third in order of birth. Joseph Hart Sperry was killed in 1846 by being thrown from a horse. Laura Ann Sperry, born October 20, 1835, married Andrew J. Randell and resided in Brooklyn, NY. She died January 25, 1879. In early life she was a school teacher. Enoch Knight Sperry born in Woodbridge married November 10, 1863 Sarah Amanda Treat who was born July 29, 1844 daughter of Jonah Newton and Mary Amanda Gould Treat, and a descendant in the ninth generation from Richard Treat who came to New England as early as 1639 and was an early settler of Wethersfield, Connecticut. Mrs. Sperry’s line of descent from Richard is through Governor Robert, Robert 2, Robert 3, Robert 4, Jonathan, Joseph, and Jonah Newton Treat, the latter a mason and builder of New Haven. Enoch K. Sperry for a number of years was the efficient accountant and bookkeeper of the City Bank of New Haven and engaged in mercantile pursuits in that city. He was appointed United States consul to Barbados by President Lincoln and served several years with honor and distinction. Later in life he had charge of the Treat estate. His wife died April 8, 1877. Their only daughter, Edith Amanda Sperry, was born January 8, 1873. Nehemiah D. Sperry our principal subject attended the schools of his native town and for two years was at the private school of Professor Amos Smith of New Haven. …

Nehemiah_D_SperryThe entry goes into much greater length in describing Nehemiah’s accomplishments, including his public service as a “former member of congress from the second district of Connecticut, former Secretary of that state, and for twenty eight years the efficient postmaster at New Haven”  — the entry continues with a very long list, indeed! — before concluding with some additional biographical information about his immediate family: “Mr. Sperry was married in 1847 to Miss Eliza H. a daughter of Willis and Catherine Sperry of Woodbridge. She died in 1873 and in 1875 he married Miss Minnie B. Newton, a native of Lockport, New York and a daughter of Erastus and Caroline Newton of that place. Their daughter Caesara married Ephraim I. Frothingham. Mr Sperry died November 13, 1911.”

nehemiah_sperry_houseNehemiah Sperry is associated with two houses of note; one here in Woodbridge, the other in New Haven. In the Woodbridge Bicentennial booklet, included on a page at the back depicting “Old Woodbridge”  is a photo captioned: “The Nehemial Sperry House, Circa 1800.” This house is no longer standing, but apparently had been located on Litchfield Turnpike, near the intersection with Bond Road and was torn down in the 1970s. Of course, if this house was built in 1800, it would pre-date Nehemiah and may instead have been inherited by him. Could it have been built by his father Enoch (1787 – 1856), or even his grandfather Simeon (1738/39 – 1805)? To shed more light on this question, it sounds like a trip to the Town Clerk’s vault may be in order…

Nehemiah_Sperry_House_New_HavenMeanwhile in New Haven, Nehemiah built a home on Orange Street in 1857, just one year after his father’s murder. This home is listed on the website for Historic Buildings of Connecticut, where further details are available.

Now the land that was left to the Town of Woodbridge, to become Sperry Park, had been known as ‘the Sperry Home Lot’ and the history of this property can be traced back a few generations, again quoting from “A Modern History of New Haven”:

The name of Sperry is familiar to those acquainted with the history of New Haven and vicinity for from almost the very dawn of the colonial period to the present members of the family has been conspicuous characters in the locality’s social and business life. … In the town of Woodbridge there is a fertile tract of land in the valley to the westward of West Rock near the Judge’s Cave so called because it was for a time the hiding place for the regicides Generals Goffe and Whalley and Colonel Dixwell who fled to America after the restoration. This tract early took the name of Sperry’s farms the home of Richard Sperry a farmer who though not one of the original planters of New Haven was an early settler his name being of record in the town as early as January 4 1643. This Richard Sperry was the last friend and protector of the regicides Goffe and Whalley at a time when their pursuers from England were trying to ferret them out of their hiding places. There is a family tradition that he came to New Haven as agent for the earl of Warwick. The tenure of Sperry’s Farms has continued for upward of two hundred and fifty years in the persons of his descendants.

I. From Richard Sperry of Sperry’s Farms are descended the sons of the late Enoch Sperry who are in the sixth generation their lineage being through Nathaniel, Nathaniel 2, Simeon, and Enoch Sperry.

II. Nathaniel Sperry son of Richard born August 13, 1656 married October 2, 1683 Sarah Dickerman who was born July 25, 1663 daughter of Abraham and Mary Cooper Dickerman and grand-daughter of Thomas Dickerman of Dorchester, 1636.

III. Nathaniel Sperry 2, son of Nathaniel born March 8, 1695 married December 25, 1719 Sarah Wilmot born February 26, 1695/96 daughter of John Wilmot. Mr. Sperry died September 8, 1751.

IV. Simeon Sperry, son of Nathaniel 2, born March 16, 1738/39, married Patience Smith. Mr. Sperry lived and died in Woodbridge his birthplace, though at the time of his birth the territory was the town of New Haven. By occupation he was a small manufacturer and farmer. He held some minor town offices. He was a man of retiring disposition but he had great decision of character and undoubted integrity, and he enjoyed the confidence of all who knew him.

V. Enoch Sperry son of Simeon born in 1787, married Mary Atlanta Sperry daughter of Asa and Eunice Johnson Sperry. Mr. Sperry was born in Woodbridge and lived on the mill site at the upper end of Sperry’s Farms where were located the gristmill and machine. Like his father he too was a small manufacturer and farmer and held a few town offices. He possessed a natural mathematical mind and would solve the most difficult problems in his own way without the rules of ordinary arithmetic. His home life was beautiful. He always had family devotion and was a sincere Christian, a man of the highest integrity and one who would go further than most men to assist those in distress or need. He was greatly interested in matters of the day and would discuss political and religious questions with great freedom and intelligence. Outside of business his chief delight was in church affairs. He was a member of the Congregational Church and often moderator of meetings, and he was frequently chosen to settle disputes both in and out of the church, his decisions being seldom questioned.

Now it’s time to head out to Sperry Park. Let’s see what remains today of this ancient story…


Panorama view of the path leading to Sperry Falls.

Panorama view of the path leading to Sperry Falls.

In order to get to Sperry Park we have to turn down Sperry Road from Dillon Road. Not too far in, the asphalt portion of modern roadway ends and the going gets bumpy as we travel “along the colonial, and still dirt, Sperry Road.” This description is quoted from the 1982 “Survey of Publicly Owned Property in Woodbridge, Connecticut” in which Sperry Park is the first parcel described, as the survey recounts the acquisition of property by the Town in chronological order. It reads in part:

The combined Sperry and Henry C. Hickox Memorial Parks land consists of five acres, more or less, on either side of Sargents River, east of Sperry Road, below the Sperry Road Bridge. They are surrounded by extensive New Haven Water Company lands. As defined in its deed, Sperry Park is “that portion of the ‘Sperry Farm’ known as ‘Home Lot’ on which the Dwelling House stood and which contains four (4) acres, more or less, bounded and described as follows, to wit, Easterly by land of New Haven Water Company, Southerly by land of said . New Haven Water Company, Westerly by land of said Water Company and by highway and Northerly by highway.”

The spring (mentioned in the deed) is on Sperry Road. The entrance to the Park is at its northwest corner and leads to a small parking lot. The tree-shaded ‘Home Lot’ is bordered on the north by an old stone wall. Cellar holes and old lilac bushes are on the crest of its hill to the north of and above the river; its land slopes down in fields and ledges to the river, Sperry Falls and small pools below and then rises sharply in the evergreen and fern covered banks south and west of the river. The old Sperry millstone can be seen and grist mill site can be detected. The wooded Hickox land of one acre, more or less, according to its deed (though an earlier deed refers to 1 and 1/4 acres) is bounded “WEST and NORTHWEST by Sperry Road; EAST by land formerly of the Heirs of Enoch Sperry, et ux; and SOUTH by land formerly of Bevil Smith. The Easterly line can be determined by a series of old stone bounds set in the ground.” Together the two Parks offer a quiet setting for walking along the colonial, and still dirt, Sperry Road; for walking through the fields and woods of the parks or sitting by the ever-flowing Sargents River, Sperry Falls and pools.

Here are some of the photos I took as we followed the path in and came to the site of the old mill and picturesque Sperry Falls — one can imagine, still as beautiful as the day Enoch last set eyes upon it.

At left: the sign found in the parking area of the park, and right: The path in... Two views of what is left of the foundation of the Sperry House. At left, the foundation of the old Mill House, located at the top of the falls, and right: a view of the old Mill Stone. Sperry Falls.

Time-lapse video of Sperry Falls.


Update #1:Indeed, there are deeds!… post coming soon… stay tuned!

Indeed, there are Deeds!

Now that we’ve returned from our Visit to Sperry Park, let’s look now at some documents! The land that makes up both Sperry Park and the adjoining Henry C. Hickox Memorial Park was donated to the Town of Woodbridge in 1907 and 1955, respectively. Just prior to the donation of the Hickox parcel, a map was drawn up from information apparently supplied by Mrs. Helen Newton.

As we take a closer look at these documents, let’s also see if we can place the people named in them. It’s remarkable how the families in this little corner of olden Woodbridge intermarried, and made transfers of property among family members over the years.

The first Deed mentioned in the CUPOP Summary for “Sperry Park and Henry C. Hickox Memorial Park” is a Quitclaim Deed from members of the Sperry family to the Town of Woodbridge in 1907. Here we find a listing of the then-living heirs of Enoch and Mary Atlanta Sperry:

Nehemiah D. Sperry, E. Knight Sperry, and Harriet S. Miller, all of New Haven, Connecticut, and Andrew J. Ramsdell, L. Atlanta Ramsdell, and G. Louise McIntosh of the Burrough of Brooklyn in the City of Greater New York

The first two individuals are Enoch and Mary’s surviving sons, Nehemiah Day and Enoch Knight. The next mentioned is their first-born son Lucien Wells Sperry and his wife Harriet A. Sperry’s only child, Harriet Sperry Miller, who was married to Eugene Spencer Miller. These three heirs are all living in New Haven in 1907.

Next we see listed the husband and surviving children of Enoch and Mary’s only daughter Laura Ann Sperry, who had died at age 43 in 1879. About three years after her father’s murder, Laura had married Andrew J. Ramsdell on January 11, 1879 and the couple had children: Laura Atlanta Ramsdell [born about 1866 and died Jan. 3, 1951, and is buried with her parents in Evergreen Cemetery in New Haven], and Grace Louise Ramsdell [born about 1870 and died after 1940] who married John A. McIntosh sometime around 1892. This couple’s only child, Laura Louise McIntosh was born Aug. 17, 1898 and died Feb. 22, 1920, and was buried in New York. Two more Ramsdell family members, Adeline S. Ramsdell [who died Sep. 14, 1915] and Elmer S. Ramsdell [who died 26 Jul 1883], are buried with Laura Ann and her husband in Evergreen Cemetery in New Haven, but their relationships are not clear.

 

Ancient Boundary Markers: Where two colonies met in old Woodbridge

On a recent visit to the Woodbridge Town Clerk’s vault, I came across a copy of an old newspaper article published in the New Haven Register on Sunday, November 26, 1933:

Battered Boulders All That Remain Of Famous Boundary

Carven Field Stones Amid Woodbridge Thickets Stand as Silent Guardians of Line Established by First Colonial Surveyors — Penalty Prevents Removal

It seems that back in 1933 lifelong Woodbridge resident S. J. Peck had finally uncovered a bit of Woodbridge history he had been searching more than 20 years to find — one of the boundary stones set out in 1672 to mark the border between what was then the Milford Colony and the New Haven Colony. These two colonies each held claims to the land that would one day be joined together to become the Town of Woodbridge when it was established in 1784. A fascinating article all by itself — you can read it here if you like. 1933_news_article But it got me thinking about several strands of history and I set out to see what else I could find to tie into the story as presented by the local newspaper in 1933.

First, who was S. J. Peck exactly? Here is a closer look at the very grainy reproduction of the photograph that ran in that Sunday’s paper. Mysterious! SJ_Peck_1933 Looking first in my genealogy data, I found a Woodbridge resident with the initials S. J. and the surname Peck who fits the approximate dates to make him roughly age 66 in 1933. He is Silas J. Peck, the son of Henry Clay Peck and Susan Cornelia Baldwin, born in 1867. I also found this Silas J. in the census records of Woodbridge in 1870:

Silas J. Peck (3, b CT); in Woodbridge, Conn. w parents and brother Newton J. (7, b CT) at res. of grandparents Silas J. Peck (62) and Mary A. Peck (58).

Then in the census of 1900, Silas appears again in his grandmother’s household after both his father Henry has died in 1898, and his grandfather Silas Julius Peck has died in 1875. Here  is S.J. at age 33 living with his wife Eva, his children (John, Hattie, Lois, and Stephen), along with his grandmother and mother: 1900_census_silas_peck To confirm that this is most likely the same S.J. Peck in the news in 1933, I looked up his death date in the Woodbridge Vital Records: it turns out to be September 1, 1943. According to this record, his full name is Silas Judson Peck. Then searching the Find-a-Grave website, we can see his gravestone standing in the Milfordside Cemetery on Racebrook Road, linked with his wife Eva’s gravestone nearby:

SJ Peck Gravestone

Silas and Eva also seem familiar to me as a couple, so I look for them in the book Historic Woodbridge and find them to be one time owners of the house at 131 Ansonia Road:

Historically important for its long association with the Baldwin-Peck family, this well-preserved house was built about 1800 by Ephraim Baldwin on property that he purchased from Colonel Alling and it descended to Silas J. Peck, the great-grandson of the original owner, in the early twentieth century. Baldwin (1766- 1835), the son of Barnabas and the grandson of the Lieutenant Barnabas who settled in Woodbridge in 1742, married Martha ? (1770-1856). In 1870 Silas J. Peck (b. 1808) was living here with his wife, Mary Adeline Baldwin (b. 1812). With them were his married son, Henry C., his daughter-in-law, and their two children. The younger child, also Silas J. (b. 1867)., who later inherited the property, married Eva S. Hollenbeck in 1889. There are several interesting stories associated with the property. One is that Captain Ephraim Baldwin, who received his title from service in the state militia, used the meadow at the rear of the house as a drill field. Also, according to local sources, the addition at the rear of the wing was originally a slave quarters on the property which was later attached to the house.

Well, those names are certainly ringing some bells! We can fill in some blanks: we have Captain Ephraim Baldwin, who was elected to represent Woodbridge in the Connecticut State Legislature and died at Hartford in 1835. He was married to Martha Newton, daughter of Lt. Samuel Newton and Mary Camp. In turn, Ephraim and Martha’s daughter, Mary Adeline Baldwin, married Silas Julius Peck and had Henry (S.J. Peck’s father) in 1839 — so this seems to certainly be the household described in both the 1870 and 1900 census records. Here is a more recent photo of the house on Ansonia Road. 131_ansonia_rd_2009 But what is the connection between Captain Ephraim Baldwin (S.J.’s great-grandfather, from whom he inherits the house at 131 Ansonia Road) and the previous owner of the land, Colonel Alling? There are two Revolutionary War Patriots named Alling buried in the Eastside Cemetery, Samuel Alling (~1715 – 1788) and his son, Roger Alling V (1741-1824). Is one of them the Colonel Alling referred to here? Hmmm… that’s a search for another day perhaps?

Let’s get back to the 1933 news article. Now that we know who S.J. is… how about the other people mentioned in the story? And, with all that knowledge of “who” will that help us figure out “where” — as in, “Would we be able to find this boundary marker today?”

clifton_roshaThe name Clifton Rosha is familiar, but he’s not a character from olden days in Woodbridge; rather he was a prominent citizen in long ago Bethany. He was a Deacon in the Congregational Church, and Tax Collector of Bethany from 1902 to 1949 (I imagine he must have known my great-great grandfather, Jerome Andrew Downs, Jr., who was First Selectman 1903-1908). I remember reading about Clifton in William Carvosso Sharpe’s Bethany Sketches & Records — here he is as pictured on page 187 (photo at right).

But where did Clifton live in 1933 when S.J. set off from his farm to find the hidden boundary marker? We have a few clues in the text of the story — Bladen Brook, Fort Hill, the Old Sheep Hole — as well as a note hand-written into the margin that corrects “Ansonia Road” to “Seymour Road.” We know Clifton Rosha lives on the Bethany side of the border with Woodbridge. Let’s look through Alice Bice Bunton’s book Bethany’s Old Houses and Community Buildings and focus on roads that border Woodbridge. Here on page 26 is a write-up of the Clark Hotchkiss House on Bethmour Road: clark_hotchkiss_house Ah, ha! Clifton Rosha is the grandson of Clark Hotchkiss and inherited his farm on Bethmour Road. And Clark is already in my genealogy data (he is my 3rd cousin, 6 times removed, which makes Clifton a distant cousin as well — and it’s a good bet that Clifton and Jerome knew in their lifetimes that they were 5th cousins, once removed). Here is Clark Hotchkiss himself (from Sharpe’s book), as well as a circa 1900 photo of his farmhouse (from Alice Bice Bunton’s book). clark_hotckiss_and_house Well, we have a rough location for this old boundary marker! Let’s take a look at a map now. According to the entry in Alice’s book, before it burned down in February 1972 the Clark Hotchkiss House stood on the east side of Bethmour Road, between Atwater Road to the north and Anella Drive to the south — approximately where I’ve marked the green x on this map (note the proximity of the Bethany-Woodbridge town line, in green, at the bottom of the image): mapAnd here is a much older map of how the Milford Colony and the New Haven Colony line looked back in the day when it was established (the hatched-in areas represent the Milford Colony territory — in the area of Woodbridge known today as “Milfordside”): milfordside_map So perhaps next steps can include a few inquiries in Bethany to see if the recent Bethany Farms subdivision project uncovered any clues to the exact whereabouts of old S.J.’s boundary stone…


silas_peckUpdate #1: I forgot to check one other source for information about S.J. Peck — A History of Woodbridge, a booklet published for the country’s bicentennial in 1976. It turns out, another reason the name seems so familiar is because he was First Selectman of Woodbridge, from 1912 to 1916. Here he is, a bit younger and more in focus.

 


Update #2: I wrote to a friend in Bethany who forwarded my inquiry to Will Brinton there. He shared the following story (readers may contact Mr. Brinton by email if you would like to know more):

     “I am somewhat familiar with the boundary stone in Bethany Farms.  I recall the newspaper article from the 1930s, with the photo of S.J. Peck pointing it out. My father was intrigued with this as well, so when Bethany Farms was being developed in the 1990s, he contacted Hiram Carrington to see if he knew where it was [S.J.’s boundary marker stone].  Indeed he did, as his father, Hiram Sr., had shown him the location years before.  Mr. Spath, the owner/engineer for the project was interested as well, so we did a site visit with Hi Carrington, Mr. Spath, my father, my brother Bob and me.  This was before any roads had been put in, so there was a lot of underbrush, but we eventually found the site.  There was no marked stone like in the photo from the 1930s — someone must have taken it as a souvenir years ago. I can’t recall if Hiram had ever seen the stone or if it was gone when his father showed him [the location]. Hi was born in 1930, so he probably saw it some time in the late 30s or early 40s.  However, there were a number of small stones on top of a large boulder to mark the spot.
     I think my father asked Mr. Spath to put the location on the subdivision map, but I don’t remember if this actually happened or not.  If I remember correctly, the site ended up in one of the open space set-asides, now owned by the Bethany Land Trust, so it should not have been disturbed by the development.”

Update #3: Another message from Will Brinton, received on July 9th 2014:

     “This morning I stopped at the Bethany Historical Society to see if we had any additional data.  The slim file includes a copy of the 1933 article, a section of the Bethany Farms subdivision map that shows the general area (but not exact location) and finally a few photographs of the site visit with Hi Carrington in 1994.
      Based on that, I drove through Bethany Farms today and was able to find the boulder pretty easily. It lies in “open space #2″, about 25 feet south of Farm View Road. Glancing at a town map, this lines up with Pole Hill Road, a modern day relic of the old Milford/New Haven boundary. It also aligns with Beacon Cap, the northeast corner of the old Milford Colony.”

Bethany Farms Trail MapWith this, I think we have solved our mystery — or perhaps more accurately, we have re-solved S.J. Peck’s mystery! If anyone would like to take a look in person at what remains of this old boundary marker, here is a link to download the map of this parcel from the Bethany Land Trust. Enjoy!

 

Sperry family in Woodbridge

Richard Sperry is said to have been the first European settler to live in what is now Woodbridge, arriving in New Haven in 1643 and farming the land here in Woodbridge possibly as early as 1648. According to page 181 of The Descendants of Thomas Dickerman:

Richard Sperry was among the early settlers of New Haven, though not one of the original planters. His name occurs Jan. 4, 1643, and again in the Court records May 2, 1648, where the entry is “Richard Sperry was complained of for not coming to watch, but Mr. Goodier answered for him that when he was neare comeing from the farme they wanted an oxe; the neager said he was sicke and left in the woods; so he was faine to goe forth to seeke hime least he should be lost.”

[Yale] President Stiles says that Stephen Goodyear, “a rich settler bought of the town [of New Haven] a tract of a thousand or twelve hundred acres of land in the fertile valley to the westward of West Rock and planted on it his farmer Richard Sperry, which farm Richard Sperry afterwards became possessed of, and it was known as Sperry’s Farm. On this tract Mr. Goodyear built Sperry a house; and in the woods about a mile south-west stood the house of Ralph Lines. These were the only two houses in 1661 between West Rock and Hudson River, except a few at Derby. All was
an immense wilderness.”

This allusion is made in describing the part which Richard Sperry played in protecting the regicides, Goffe and Whalley. At the time when pursuers from England were trying to ferret out their hiding place, three friends, William Jones, Richard Sperry and another by the name of Burril, led them out of town into this wilderness, and here they were kept safely concealed. The first retreat was at a place three or four miles from town to which the fugitives gave the name of  “Hatchet Harbor,” from a hatchet they found with which to build a shelter. Then after two nights they were taken up the cliff, which they named “Providence Hill,” and here a pile of huge rocks was shown them under whose arching sides a better lodging could be made, while the elevation gave a commanding view of the town and the bay. This group of rocks is still known as “The Judges’ Cave.”

Here they continued from the 15th of May to the 11th of June 1661: usually spending their nights at the cave, as well as days, but sometimes in stormy weather going down to the house of their guardian. ” Richard Sperry daily supplied them with food; sometimes carrying it himself, at other times sending it by one of his boys, tied up in a cloth, ordering them to lay it on a certain stump and leave it: and when the boy went there at night he always found the basons emptied of the provisions, and brought them home. Upon the boy’s wondering and asking what it meant he
was told that there was somebody at work in the woods that wanted it.”

One night a panther, or some other wild animal, visited them at this spot and frightened them so that they dared not sleep there again and had to find another place to hide. Probably Richard Sperry was the only person who knew their exact whereabouts, and he kept the secret so well that the king’s officers pursued a vain search.”

Richard Sperry and his wife Denis had ten children and over sixty grandchildren. It is said that everyone in North America with the surname Sperry descend from Richard and Denis. According to page 684 of The Tuttle Family the couple’s ten children were:

  1. John, born Jan. 9, 1649, married Sep. 1, 1676, Elizabeth Post
  2. Mary, born March 14, 1650, married March 29, 1670, Benjamin Peck
  3. Richard, Jr. born Jan. 20, 1652, married Dec. 16, 1680, Martha Mansfield
  4. Hester, born Sep. 1654, married June 21,1683, Daniel Hotchkiss
  5. Nathaniel, born Aug. 13, 1656, married Oct. 2, 1683, Sarah Dickerman
  6. Thomas, born July 13, 1658, married Nov. 18, 1684, Elizabeth Fearne
  7. a child, born 1661, died young
  8. Ebenezer, born July 1663, married Jan. 21, 1689, Abigail Dickerman
  9. Daniel, born 1665, married April 3, 1694, Deborah Peck
  10. Joseph, born July 24, 1668, married and had a son Joseph

 

Johnson family in Woodbridge

Clues to the origin of the Johnson clan in Connecticut can be found in Families of Ancient New Haven by Donald Lines Jacobus. On page 1029 he states:

“Three Johnson brothers, said to have come from Hull, Yorkshire, England, settled early in New Haven, Connecticut; these were Johnwho removed to Rowley, Massachusetts and died in 1641 leaving issue; Robert (see Family 1); and Thomas (see Family 2). A Dutchman, Richard Johnson (also called Derrick) settled in New Haven and died 23 May 1679; his heir, probably a nephew, was William Johnson (also called Wingle, see Family 16). Another Dutchman, Walter Johnson (see Family 39) settled at Wallingford, Connecticut.”

But another source connects William/Wingle Johnson directly as a son of Robert (and nephew of John and Thomas). It is therefore possible that William’s uncle Richard/Derrick was a fourth brother, and may have come to New Haven by way of the Netherlands, but was originally also from Hull, Yorkshire, England. This additional source is a history of Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, where William/Wingle’s great-grandson, the Rev. Jacob Johnson lived and died in 1797. In a lengthy footnote beginning on page 744, it states:

Jacob Johnson was born at Wallingford, New Haven County Connecticut, April 7, 1718 the youngest child of Sergeant Jacob and Abigail Hitchcock Johnson. Sergeant Johnson was second cousin of Deacon Samuel Johnson, 1670-1727, of Guilford, Connecticut who was the father the Rev Samuel Johnson D.D., the father of Episcopacy in Connecticut (as mentioned in the note page 478) — the paternal grandfathers of the Deacon and the Sergeant having been brothers, and immigrants to Boston from Kingston on Hull, England about the year 1638. Thomas Johnson, grandfather of Sergeant Jacob Johnson, settled in New Haven where in 1640 he was drowned in harbor. He was survived by his wife Helena and four sons, the youngest of whom, William, a native of England, settled in New Haven where he was married in December 1664 to Sarah Hall. He was mason by trade. In 1670 with some thirty seven other men he signed the original compact for the settlement of Wallingford and thus became one of the original proprietors of that town. However he continued to reside at New Haven where he died in 1716. William and Sarah Hall Johnson were parents of thirteen children, the sixth of whom was Sergeant Jacob Johnson, previously mentioned, who was bom at New Haven September 25, 1674. He was married December 14, 1698 to Abigail (born 1674, died January 9 1726) daughter of John and Abigail Merriman Hitchcock of Wallingford, and settled in that town where he became an extensive land owner. He was a Deputy from Wallingford to the General Court of Connecticut in 1721, 1732, 1733, and 1736, and for some time was Sergeant of the Wallingford train-band. He died at Wallingford July 17, 1749.”


wilkes-barre_coverA history of Wilkes-Barré, Luzerne County, Pennsylvania, from its first beginnings to the present time: including chapters of newly-discovered early Wyoming Valley history, together with many biographical sketches and much genealogical material, Volume 2, 1909 (Google eBook)

 

 

History of the Town of Woodbridge, Connecticut

This website is dedicated to telling the story of the land and people of Woodbridge from its earliest days as a community. Many of the families of the original European settlers are still living in Woodbridge.

Woodbridge_1868The community of Woodbridge was founded in the mid-1600s by families who came from the New Haven Colony and the Milford Colony to the land that was later to become the Town of Woodbridge.

If you have information or photos you would like to share, or a story you would like to tell, please get in touch by email or phone (203-389-4203). Meanwhile, welcome to the website! Please look around…